Archive for the ‘allure’ Category

Idol-theft case, where the Idol-wing Police themselves involved- the accused DSP absconding and the current IGP transferred!

July 2, 2017

Idol-theft case, where the Idol-wing Police themselves involved- the accused DSP absconding and the current IGP transferred!

TN Govt Idol wing- officers.contact nos

In 1980, there was sudden increase in theft of Panchaliga idols – Idol Wing Police – History[1]: Idol theft cases were investigated by a small team of officials in CB-CID till the year 1980. During the year 1980 there was a sudden increase in thefts of Panchaloga idols. The thefts of such idols from the temples affected the sentiments of the local people. A proposal was initiated by the Director-General of Police to re-organize the strength allotted for investigating the idol theft cases. The Government accepted the proposal, constituted Idol Wing CID Vide G.O.Ms.No.2098 Home (Police IV) Dept Dt. 7.10.1983, with 1 SP, 1 DSP, 5 Inspectors, 3 SIs, 4 HCs, 3 Gr.I PCs and 13 Gr.II PCs. The unit functions from the Head Quarters, Chennai.  In the year 2000, CB-CID was bifurcated and Idol Wing was brought under the control of Economic Offences Wing in accordance with the order issued in the Chief Office Proceedings Rc.No.RAI (2)/273552/98 dt.30.12.1999. At present Idol Wing CID is headed by DIG-Idol Wing and assisted by one DSP and 5 Inspectors of Police.

Primary functions of the Idol Wing CID

  • To investigate cases of theft of idols and antiques exceeding value of Rs.5 Lakhs.
  • To investigate idol theft cases referred to it by the State Government.
  • To co-ordinate in the investigation of important idol theft cases handled by the District Police
  • Collection of intelligence on nefarious activities of antique dealers and art collectors.

 However, the idol teft in Tamilnadu has been going on obviously with the connivance of the persons involved at temple, idol-wing police, atheist politicians and others.

TN Govt Idol wing- officer- Khader bhatcha

2008 case dragged up to 2017[2]:  In May 2008, idols recovered by Arociaraj was attempted to be sold to somebody through his accomplicw Subburaj. At that time Khader Batcha intervened and brought them to Chennai. Later he sold to some agent. According to Rajendran, he found a cover kept under his car wiper on April 12 last, which stated that one Arockiaraj of Aladipatty in Aruppukottai taluk found two panchaloha idols — Sivagamy Amman and Siva Parvathy -on a pedestal. Instead of handing them over to the police, they tried to sell the same to a foreigner in collusion with one Santhanam of the same village. However, two cops caught them red-handed and handed them over to police inspector Kader Batcha. The accused sub inspector Subburaj, 54, currently serving in Koyambedu police station, was serving as a head constable in 2008 in the Idol Wing when he, along with inspector Kader Batcha, is said to have obtained the antique idols from the farmer and sold them to another smuggler Deenadayalan, who is currently facing many idol smuggling cases, for Rs.15 lakh.

Pon Manickavel, IG (Idol Wing)

In January 2017, a case was registered against Kader Batcha, Subburaj and a few others[3]: The incident surfaced only in January 2017, when the idol wing registered a case against Kader Batcha, Subburaj and a few others. The case did not see much progress and in the course of years Kader Batcha was promoted as Deputy Superintendent of Police and is now serving in Tiruvallur district. Subburaj was promoted as a sub inspector of police and was serving in Koyambedu police station. While Subburaj was arrested on Monday 26-06-2017, the Idol Wing officers said Kader Batcha was absconding. A case has been filed under IPC provisions for alleged offences including robbery, or dacoity with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt, said Inspector-General of Police A G Ponn Manickavel. On Tuesday 27-06-2017, the petitioner informed the court that the case is now handled by an Inspector, who cannot effectively handle the same as the accused Kader Batcha is a DSP. Contending that it was a case of fence grazing the crop, the petitioner prayed the court to transfer the case to CBCID. A police sub inspector, one of the accused in an idol smuggling case, was arrested by Idol wing of the Economic Offences Wing on 26-06-2017 Monday. The arrest was made a day before the Madras High Court heard a petition seeking transfer of the case from the Idol Wing to CBCID. Justice R Mahadevan, before whom the petition from advocate ‘elephant’ G Rajendran came up for hearing on 27-06-2017, Tuesday, orally directed the Inspector-General of Police, Idol Wing Pon Manickavel to appear before him with all records of the case, on June 29.

Deenadayalan idol snuggler
Madras High Court questioned as to why the tainted DSP was not arrrsted?
: A day after the Madras High Court questioned the top brass of the state idol wing police as to why police personnel of their own wing involved in illegal sale of ancient panchaloha idols for several crores of rupees have not yet been arrested, the state government told the court that it had placed deputy superintendent of police Khader Batcha under suspension[4]. The judge orally asked the APP, “Why you have not arrested them. Don’t you know their whereabouts?”  The APP, Emilias said it will take some time to know their whereabouts[5]. The judge also asked Pon Manickavel what was the strength of the Idol Wing department. After Pon Manickavel explained the details, the judge asked him to file an affidavit as to what was the requirement and how many staff he requires. The judge posted to June 30, further hearing of the case. The judge also adjourned to July 21, 2017, the hearing on another petition filed by Rajendran, which sought a direction to the authorities to provide police protection to him and to his family[6]. In his petition, Rajendran alleged that he received information on Thursday that a high ranking police officer made a comment on him stating that “He always gives trouble to the government by filing petitions, harassed real estate persons, now he filed a petition against police. I will teach a lesson to him”. He sought to transfer the investigation of idol theft case to CB-CID.

Khader Bhatcha case - Indian Express 28-06-2017

The police assured that effective steps were being taken to arrest him (absconding DSP): When Justice R Mahadevan took up the matter for hearing on Friday [30-06-2017], special government pleader M. Maharaja and additional public prosecutor C. Emilias submitted that the DSP, Khader Batcha, suspected to have been involved in the idol theft and sale case, was placed under suspension with effect from June 29, 2017[7]. A sub-inspector, who was an associate of Batcha, has already been arrested. Though Batcha is absconding, there were rumours on Friday [30-06-2017] that he had been arrested near Andhra Pradesh border. The two law officers also furnished a copy of the suspension order before the court. They told Justice Mahadevan that effective steps were being taken to arrest him and that police would proceed with further investigation including recovery of idols in the case. The HR & CE department will cooperate with the police in the investigation, they said. As for Justice Mahadevan’s queries with regard to the staff strength at the idol wing police and vacancies dogging it, the law officers produced a circular issued by the DGP, allotting 20 police personnel, including a deputy superintendent of police, an inspector and a sub-inspector to the idol wing[8]. The judge then reserved his orders on the PIL, filed by advocate and activist Elephant G Rajendran[9].

TN Govt Idol wing- officer- Khader bhatcha-2

Absconding DSP suspected to be hiding in Kerala[10]: CB-CID Idol Wing officers have intensified their search to nab Deputy Superintendent of Police Kadher Batcha, who has been suspended on for his alleged involvement in the illegal export of antique idols in 2008[11]. The news reports say that he was in Kerala or Andhra border hiding in a Ayurvedic clinic or resort. A.G. Ponn Manickavel, Inspector General of Police, Idol Wing CID, appeared before the Madras High Court and explained the details of the case to Justice R. Mahadevan who heard the plea moved by an advocate seeking transfer of the probe into a multi-crore idol theft case registered against two officials of the Idol Wing to the CB-CID[12]. Recording the appearance of IG, Justice Mahadevan orally instructed the prosecutor’s office to get instructions from the jurisdictional Superintendent of Police, Tiruvallur, as to why the police official involved in the crime was not yet arrested and file a report.

Subash Kapoor

Case background as reported in “The Hindu”[13]: Manickavel told The Hindu, “We have zeroed in on the probable whereabouts of Batcha and teams have been sent to Kerala following inputs that he might be hiding there.” In 2008, Sundaramoorthy, a professional photographer, who was running a studio in South Mada Street in Madurai and was involved in selling antique idols, had displayed photos of antique idols. Batcha, who was an Inspector at the time, and Subburaj, then a head constable in the Idol Wing, quizzed Sundaramoorthy about the photos displayed. Following information given by him, the officers apprehended Arokiaraj, a resident of Aladipatti of Aruppukottai Taluk in Virudhunagar, who was trying sell some idols recovered from his agricultural land to a foreign national. Police sources said Arokiaraj and Sundaramoorthy were interrogated at a guest house in Virudhunagar but they escaped from there. The idols were in the custody of Mr. Batcha who, along with Mr. Subburaj, tried to sell them to Deenadayalan, an international antique dealer, for Rs. 50 lakh. As Deenadayalan was reluctant to buy the idols, they reportedly forced him to buy the idols for Rs. 25 lakh. The idols found their way to Manhattan gallery owner Subhash Kapoor, who is in Puzhal Prison.

© Vedaprakash

30-06-2017

Deenadayalan, Subhash Kapoor, Khader Batcha

[1] http://www.tneow.gov.in/IDOL/IW_history.html

[2] Indian Express, Plea to shift theft case from idol wing to CBCID; SI held, DSP on the run, By Express News Service  |   Published: 28th June 2017 01:50 AM  |  Last Updated: 28th June 2017 07:54 AM.

[3] http://www.newindianexpress.com/states/tamil-nadu/2017/jun/28/plea-to-shift-theft-case-from-idol-wing-to-cbcid-si-held-dsp-on-the-run-1621673.html

[4] Times of India, DSP tainted by idol theft charge suspended: Tamil Nadu, TNN | Updated: Jul 1, 2017, 12.35 PM IST.

[5] Deccan Herald, Why cops in idol theft case not held, Madras HC asks govt, PublishedJun 30, 2017, 1:49 am IST; UpdatedJun 30, 2017, 4:26 am IST

[6] http://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/in-other-news/300617/why-cops-in-idol-theft-case-not-held-madras-hc-asks-govt.html

[7]  http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chennai/dsp-tainted-by-idol-theft-charge-suspended-tn/articleshow/59393078.cms

[8] Business Standard, DySP accused in idol case suspended: TN govt informs HC, Press Trust of India  |  Chennai June 30, 2017 Last Updated at 19:15 IST.

[9] http://www.business-standard.com/article/pti-stories/dysp-accused-in-idol-case-suspended-tn-govt-informs-hc-117063000966_1.html

[10] The Hindu, Absconding DSP suspected to be hiding in Kerala,, Chennai, June 30, 2017 00:00 IST; Updated: JUNE 30, 2017 04:49 IST.

[11] Bureaucracy Today, Suspended accused DSP: TN govt to HC, PTI/Agencies, Chennai , Saturday July 1 2017 18:52:44.

[12] http://bureaucracytoday.com/judiciary_watch_news.aspx?id=82274

[13]http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/tp-tamilnadu/dsp-wanted-in-idols-smuggling-case-suspected-to-be-hiding-in-kerala/article19182589.ece

Online sexual grooming, luring girls with modus operandi, cyber sexual crimes: Should be taken serious and monitored!

May 18, 2017

Online sexual grooming, luring girls with modus operandi, cyber sexual crimes: Should be taken serious and monitored!

Internet grooming

Ibrahim posing as “Siva” developed Fracebook friendship with a 13-year school girl: Accepting what seemed like an innocuous Facebook friend request ended up in a nightmare for a a 13-year-old girl from Tirupur, as the friendly stranger turned out to be a sexual predator, facebook friend for just few months, who ensnared the young teen and raped her. A 22-year-old man and a lodge manager were arrested on 01-05-2017 Monday on charges of raping a 13-year-old 8th standard schoolgirl. The man, who befriended the girl from Tirupur on Facebook, took her to Puducherry, raped her and abandoned her in a lodge. Later, the lodge manager also raped her. The arrested persons were identified as S Ibrahim, 22, of Pichampalayampudur in Tirupur and E Prabhakaran, 29, of Puducherry[1]. Police said Ibrahim was working in a textile unit in Tirupur and Prabhakaran had taken a lodge on lease more than six months ago[2].

Internet sexual grooming

The girl eloped with Ibrahim as he talked so sweetly: Lured by the 21-year-old youth’s sweet-talk, the teenager ran away with him to Chennai and then to Puducherry, where she was sexually abused for two days[3]. It is ridiculous that that the 13-year girl could be so bold enough to elope with a stranger from Tirupr to Chennai to Puducherry and accepted to stay in lodge. The girl’s harrowing tale came to light on April 29, 2017 when she reached Tirupur two days after she went missing and narrated her ordeal to her parents[4]. On April 27, the girl’s parents lodged a complaint with the Tirupur North police claiming their 13-year-old daughter had gone missing. But, what the parents were doing about her activities with phone, facebook friendship, strange behaviour and other activities. They must have watched her. Even as the sleuths were trying to trace her whereabouts, she returned on her own two days later. What the girl had to tell about the two days away from home swung the city police into action, leading to the arrest of a 21-year-old youth from Chennai and a 27-year-old man from Puducherry. Police said the girl became friends with Siva (21) on Facebook recently. Over time, Siva talked her into eloping with him and on April 27, he reached Tirupur. The girl gave her family members the slip and eloped with Siva to Chennai. After a brief stay there, Siva took her to a lodge in neighbouring Puducherry, where he allegedly raped her for two days. Ironically, though TOI mentions his name as Ibrahim, Indian Express does not, perhaps on the principles of “Secular journalism”!

Internet sexual grooming- love jihad too.jpg

The lover sold her gold chain and vanished: Later, Siva sold her gold chain weighing one sovereign, gave her the return fare to Tirupur and vanished. Really, it is interesting and intriguing to note as to how the girl could giv her chain also to the crook after all these happenings. Ibrahm should be interrogated thoroughly and his modus operandi should be ex;posed, so that the girls could be safe. Finding the girl all alone, lodge owner Prabakaran (27) befriended the girl under the guise of helping her reach Tirupur. After realising what had happened, Prabakaran too allegedly sexually abused her[5]. The girl managed to escape from the lodge and reach Tirupur with the money Siva had left her. After hearing her tale, a team of sleuths traced Siva to Chennai and arrested him on 01-05-2017 (Monday) on charges of kidnapping and raping a minor girl[6]. Another team nabbed Prabakaran from his lodge in Puducherry. Both the accused have been booked under various sections of the Indian Penal Code and the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO). After all these happenings, the media started disciurse on “online sexual grooming” and so on!

Be smart in internet-1.jpg

Online sexual grooming – definition and so on![7]: Child grooming is generally understood as the practice of befriending and forming an emotional bond with a child by a person with the objective of sexual abuse. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the word ‘grooming’ was first used in connection with a paedophile in a 1985 story by Chicago Tribune which stated, “These ‘friendly molesters’ become acquainted with their targeted victim, gaining their trust while secretly grooming the child as a sexual partner.” Child grooming incidents have increased with the advent of the internet, where such incidents are increasingly taking place online, through public chatrooms and social media. In India too, such instances have been reported in the past[8].

  1. Last year, two teenagers were arrested in Kolkata for kidnapping and rape of a 15-year-old girl whom they had befriended on Facebook.
  2. Another instance of online grooming was reported in December 2016 where a teenage girl was raped by a Facebook friend in Mumbai.
  3. More recently, in January 2017, a minor girl in Cuttack alleged rape by a boy whom she had met through a social networking site.

With the proliferation of smartphone users in India, child grooming incidents can only be expected to rise in future.

Be smart in internet-2

Tulir’s discourse on Online sexual grooming[9]: As usual after some days, the analysis comes  in this way: “This is a classic case of sexual grooming,” says Vidya Reddy, of Tulir, Centre for Prevention and Healing of Child Sexual Abuse. “Abusers study a situation carefully to understand what a child’s Achilles heel is and then exploit the situation. Now, with almost every child having accesses to technology and internet in the form of a laptop or phone, these criminals have found new platforms to target children,” she adds. What Vidya explains is called online sexual grooming, a worldwide phenomenon, that has spread along with the speed and easy access to the internet. According to UNICEF, it can be defined as preparing a child or adult for sexual abuse, exploitation or ideological manipulation. A report released by the organisation in 2014 states that the surge in mobile and internet usage in India had brought 400 million people online. Of this, seven percent of internet users in the country are reportedly children. “Phones are now an extension of our hands and it has completely changed the way crime is committed and presented,” Vidya notes. Even a report of the Parliamentary Committee on Information Technology in 2014 recognized the threat posed to children by predatory paedophiles online. It emphasises how these predators “conceal their true identity whilst using the internet to ‘groom’ potential victims for sexual purposes.”

From home to horror[10]: The girl, Meena [name changed] too was unaware about the identity of the person she was chatting with. In fact, an officer told The News Minute, that it was only when Ibrahim called her on the phone that she even realised she had compromised all her data to an unknown man. But Ibrahim, as the police put it, was too smart for the girl. “He spoke to her very nicely and formed an emotional connect before she even realised the dangers of the situation,” a police officer told The News Minute. “He was just somebody who did odd jobs for a living but his real life was on Facebook. He has close to 5000 friends and they are all young girls,” she admits.

What parents and others should do?: As the issue has bee n so simple and as well as complicated in modern times, the following are suggested,  though, the modern ones might object on the grounds of “moral-policing” and so on:

  1. In schoools, moral education classes should be introduced naking them understand, realize and appreciate the moral values of family, parents, relations, respect to elders and connected issues.
  2. Of course, parents and elders should set example to their children, boys and girls and others.
  3. The studying teenage boys and girls should concentrate in studies and not in love, love-making, sex related topics.
  4. The cinema, TV, print and electronic media and connected persons should have some sort of “Social respinsibility” in their presentation of ads, news, serials etc.
  5. They should avoid negative suggestion, instread, present wth positive asppects giving good examples.
  6. Definitely, parents should watch the activities of their children, boys and girls carefully.
  7. Their extra-cautious activities should be monitored with the time-spending, money-requirement and spening, goingout on various pretexts etc.
  8. That teens from slums could kidnap and enjoy life with rich girls, autowalas, coolies and others also could join sucg fray to get girls just by wearing jeans, riding a bike, and such other iditic myths should not be promoted.
  9. The cine songs, depiction etc, should have some decency and decorum, instead of portraying the dancing actresses as whores, or they would go with anybody and indulge in sex immediately.
  10. The law enforcing auhtorities can monitor all these activities.

© Vedaprakash

18-05-2017

[1] Times of India, Girl raped by Facebook ‘friend’, lodge manager in Puducherry, TNN | Updated: May 3, 2017, 06.50 AM IST

[2] http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/coimbatore/girl-raped-by-facebook-friend-lodge-manager-in-puducherry/articleshow/58487399.cms

[3] Onmanorama, Minor girl elopes with FB friend, only to be abused by him, Wednesday 03 May 2017 08:54 PM IST, byOur Correspondent.

http://english.manoramaonline.com/news/nation/2017/05/03/chennai-girl-elopes-with-fb-friend-abused.html

[4] http://english.manoramaonline.com/news/nation/2017/05/03/chennai-girl-elopes-with-fb-friend-abused.html

[5] Indian Express, Facebook friend rapes 13-year-old after luring her from Tirupur to Chennai,

By Vignesh A, Express News Service, Published: 02nd May 2017 09:58 PM, Last Updated: 02nd May 2017 09:58 PM.

[6] http://www.newindianexpress.com/states/tamil-nadu/2017/may/02/facebook-friend-rapes-13-year-old-after-luring-her-from-tirupur-to-chennai-1600249.html

[7] Firstpost, Child grooming: India must take measures to protect children from online sexual abuses, Devika Agarwal, May, 11 2017 21:59:53 IST

[8] http://www.firstpost.com/india/child-grooming-india-must-take-measures-to-protect-children-from-online-sexual-abuse-3438528.html

[9] TheNewsMinute, A 13-year-old’s rape in TN highlights the major threat online sexual groomih poses to children, Priyanka Thirumurthy, Saturday, May 06, 2017 – 11:45

[10] http://www.thenewsminute.com/article/13-year-old-s-rape-tn-highlights-major-threat-online-sexual-grooming-poses-children-61591